Sunday, November 15, 2026

John Mulaney/Phoebe Bridgers (11.14.2026)

CIA Headquarters

  • Huh, Mulaney in a cold open. That's a first. As this goes on, Mulaney being the anchor of this makes sense as a lot of it seems to be in his voice.
  • I like the premise of this. I like that they're reusing Jane and Jeremys' Dario and Elon impressions. I'm liking JAJs' take on Peter Thiel, too. He might be tge highlight of this. 
  • This is at least a clever take on this weeks' Nividia/FAA/Outlook scandals (even if it's a bit reminiscent of a two month old South Park episode and feels like a reworked version of the "Pete Davidson as Tom Homan" cold open from January).
  • Hey, THERE'S the obligatory "Bowen as Jensen" cameo everyone's been predicting. I can't tell if his whole "I'm doing this under duress and as begrudgingly as possible" vibe was an intentional character beat or not, but...at least it's nice to see Bowen again.
  • This is a strong contender for "best cold open of the season" so far. I mean, I know that's not saying a lot (this was, of course a bit too long and lacked an ending...shocker, I know) but it's nice to see them break out of their rote cold open formulas for once. C+


Monologue

  • Hmm...well, it is nice to see Mulaney back on this show again doing some of his old standup.
  • While this whole premise of "boomer men have always been autistic" doesn't feel completely original, I do like how John is tying it back to his father and his own childhood. I also like him comparing the Greatest Generation to Gen Z as well.
  • I wasn't that into the "toddler with a hoarse voice" bit but I dug how he tied that into a sudden RFK Jr impression (and how he turned that into a very pointed criticism of RFK Jrs' actual past as an environmental lawyer once her realized he can only do that impression for so long). Good bit to end this monologue on. B+


Air Turkey Flight

  • Hmm...the audience seems...unresponsive to this right out of the gate. Seems a bit strange for this week.
  • Smart of them to place an airport sketch right after the monologue.
  • Ah, once I heard the words "Air Turkey" I should've figured this would've been a hair transplant sketch.
  • John's performing this exactly as I would expect him to. Ben's not doing much for me but I do like what Marcello Hernandez, Mikey "Gooble Gobble" Day and Jane Kardashian-Wickline are bringing to this.
  • JAJ and Sarah made the most of their thankless roles in this. C+



Sister

  • Tommy Brennan playing John Mulaneys' elderly father? That's certainly an...interesting choice.
  • 😬
  • Oh, wow. Ok, umm...this is...actually hitting quite close to home for me right n...AH, really wish I had phrased that differently.
  • 😬 😬

  • Um, yeah...I don't know what else I can say about this without revealing more about my own family situation than you would care to hear
  • ...but, I will just say that both my sister and I are doing everything we can for mom and dad right now, leave it at that and move on.

  • 😬😬😬 B-



Kathy Returns

  • HEY! Smart choice to bring this back.
  • I really like the added hurdle of Ashley's character somehow winding up at her coworker's outside the office/after work social gathering.
  • This mostly hit the same beats as the first one but I liked the ringtones and I got a kick out of Angry Mulaneys' sudden urge to fight her.
  • I don't know if the ending of "coworkers trick themselves into thinking Kathy left" but otherwise it was nice seeing this in the first third of the show to keep the momentum going. B+



Getting It Done w/Chris Gut

  • Huh...has John Mulaney ever worn a beard in an SNL sketch? It's such an...unusual visual this...feels like it HAS to be a first of some kind.
  • Welp...rather long buildup to the disappointing reveal of this being another "lol sublimated homosexuality" but...Jeremy Culhane and John Mulaney are really the only two men I would ever care to see execute this premise. I mean, John especially knows his audience well enough to know how this would play. You gotta give him credit there.
  • I liked Jeremy's acting in the parts where he had to play off his wrestling with his own confused feelings for John's character as if they were actually a pre-planned part of the show (especially as he screamed at Jane's character). C+


Weekend Update w/Jost & Che

  • Josts' Best Jokes: Ferry Transportation/As Of Now, JD Vance/Iran Negotiations, Marco Rubio
  • Ches' Best Jokes: Markwayne Mullin/Not A 9/11, RFK Jr.
  • Dammit, Colin. You just HAD to go and make that same hacky ass Airplane! reference that every tenth person in my various social media feeds made today, didn't you?
  • Boy, this Update sure feels like a long walk to the first commentary, huh? I was starting to think Update guests were going to be one of two major things this episode just wouldn't have (until I saw the animal costumes during the next commercial break).
  • Tommy Brennan brings out the keyboard? Boy, Jane must be pretty pissed.
  • Yeah, lyrically this ain't doing shit for me. The singing from him is fine and I liked the whole run about his mean sister coming out got me simply on its virtue of the least bland part of this but the rest was pretty "meh". Sorry, Blaze. C+

Central Park Horse Drawn Carriage

  • Ah, HERE it is!
  • Boy, even in the Pete Davidson/Chris Redd role Kam Patterson sticks out like a sore thumb here.

  • I do like this "Little Park Of Horrors" opening number, but...it feels...wrong for this to be Grace's first appearance of the night, doesn't it? 
  • I mean, I'd kinda expect them to do Saidah this dirty (while also secretly hoping that she'd take Egos' old role in another "Cha Cha Slide/Cupid Shuffle sketch before quickly realizing SNL may not have enough black cast members besides her to pull another one of those off) but...man... 
  • There was once a time when Mulaney hosting meant the featured players would actually get some substantial airtime if not a full fledged show case. Granted, that may have only happen the first time he hosted with that "Horns" sketch, but...we used to be a country. A proper country, y'know? Anyway, putting that minor rant aside...

  • These certainly hit different when you have performers in your cast like Veronika and Tommy who have the singing chops to actually belt these Broadway parodies out. I actually liked their numbers the most out of this.
  • So far, the only part of this I really didn't care for was Kenan dressed up as a weed cloud. The JAJ/Jeremy "Mamdani" to the tune of "Maria" two hander was a little convoluted but they performed it well.
  • Hahahahaha...okay, I do like this Kathy call back out of nowhere.
  • Hey, it's Bowen again! I guess his cameo this week was pre-planned. He did well here. I can see how they'd want to use this as a stealth plug for his current "Oh, Mary" run on Broadway.
  • Overall, in spite of a rather weak closing number, I'd say I liked this about as much as I liked the one from the 50th anniversary and all the others. The only ones I liked this one more than were "Subway Churro" and "Bus Milk" (hell, the only thing I genuinely remember from that one is Andy Samberg singing "Baby Bear Carcass" to "Alexander Hamilton"). C+


Woodstock, 1969
  • Hahaha ha, ok...this stuff has all been said before countless times too but I just love how right out of the gate this sketch just makes no bones about being a blatant Mulaney style criticism of every shitty thing the baby boomer generation did to millenials since 1985. I love it. B-


Ranking Season 52 From Best To Worst
  1. John Mulaney/Phoebe Bridgers (11.14.2026)
  2. Dakota Johnson/Turnstile (10.03.2026)
  3. Druski/The Strokes (11.07.2026)
  4. Inde Navarette/Gracie Abrams (10.31.2026)
  5. Shane Gillis/Rosalia (10.10.2026)
  6. Jalen Brunson/KATSEYE (09.26.2026)

Ranking Each John Mulaney Episode (Best To Worst)
  1. John Mulaney/Thomas Rhett (03.02.2019)
  2. John Mulaney/Jack White (03.14.2018)
  3. John Mulaney/LCD Soundsystem (02.26.2022)
  4. John Mulaney/Phoebe Bridgers (11.14.2026)
  5. John Mulaney/Chappell Roan (11.02.2024)
  6. John Mulaney/David Byrne (02.29.2020)
  7. John Mulaney/The Strokes (10.31.2020)


Overall Thoughts

  • Hey, look at that! Mulaney stops by to host and suddenly this damn show gets it's fucking shit together for a week! Who would've thought?
  • Seriously though, this was by far the strongest episode of the season so far. Of course, it had a low bar to clear but we still have more than half of the season left to go, so let's hope it doesn't just peak there because I now have sufficient hope for season 52 of SNL to get substantially better.
  • Of course, Mulaney dominated this episode (and I'm sure Bowen will dominate the discourse surrounding it) but if I had to name any cast members who's contributions really stood out for both better and worse I'd name JAJ, Ben, Ashley, Jane, Veronika, Tommy and Jeremy.
  • Sadly, Grace took her first real hit of the night and Saidah continues to ve barely visible but I have a feeling their luck will turn around.


Closing Thoughts

  • In three weeks, Amanda Seyfried makes her hosting debut. It's nice to see we'll get another first time actress host with considerable range this season. This one should be fun. I just hope they don't biff it. 
  • December shows are usually strong. I'm looking forward to finding out who the last two host and musical guest combos are of 2026 and I hope they're strong ones, too.
  • Also, the We Heart Hader podcast is on a brief indefinite hiatus right now for personal reasons (my own only) but I'll let you know as soon as Deej and I decide to resume things. See you soon!

No comments:

Post a Comment