Okay here's my review. This show really took some bold chances writing wise and thankfully most of them paid off very well. Of course, thats' to be expected with such an avant garden host as James Franco who can be game for just about anything. While he delivered almost exactly what I expected, he seemed to dominate the show to the point where he almost overshadowed the cast in terms of airtime and visibility. Still, aside from him Heidi Gardner, Kate McKinnon, Cecily Strong, Chris Redd and Beck Bennett seemed to be dominating the show so good on them. Some say this was the best show of the season up to this point. I would hesitate to say that but it's definitely in my top three. Anyway, lets' break it down.
Visit With Santa - This was quite long and uneven for what is was. It was okay overall, but they should've cut some dialogue between dress and air. It felt like thry were just throwing everything topical from this week at the wall and not even bothering to pay attention to what was sticking. Throughout most of this, I kept trying to think back to the last time they used actual children for these types of sketches (or at least gave them this much dialogue). That was probably because I was just watching the Jack Black/Neil Young episode before this where they used Dratch, Samberg and Poehler for the kid parts in the Cheney/Santa open. Then again, this cold open did seem to need actual children in order to achieve the intended effect. Plus, I was also trying to think back to the last time SNL did a non-political cold open like this (I genuinely could not remember) until I realized this actually was political to a small degree and was therefore the closest thing to a non-political cold open the show seems to think they can afford right now. Still, anytime we get a break from Alec Baldwins' Trump impression is refreshing. Kate got in some great lines, Kenan was serviceable and as far as the kids...all I can remember right now is how those boys got the biggest laughs referencing the NFL/Matt Lauer scandals and how adorable it was when that other girl had a hard time actually saying "libtard response".C+
Monologue - I did like how they tried to poke fun at themselves at first but this disappointed and went nowhere fast. Kudos to the two new writers who got some early screen time in this. The Rogen cameo was to be expected. He had a decent exchange with Franco but otherwise he didn't do much for me. Jonah Hill is officially unsettlingly skinny now and even Steve Martin couldn't add much to this. I'm sure I'm not the only one who was at least a little disappointed that they didn't use this opportunity to bust out a Tommy Wiseau cameo but he does strike me as someone the writers may be afraid to work with and even now SNL might consider "The Room" too much of a cult niche film for their audience to recognize. C-
Sexual Harassment Charlie - This was a bit strange at first but Kenan performance and Becks' laundry list of real reasons he was fired really made it for me. The ladies in the cast really played well off him too. If this sketch was actually trying to make a real point about sexual harassment (seemingly the opposite of the ones the show usually tries to make about these types of issues) then I'm glad this tried to veer away from it quick enough to score some genuine laughs. C-
Gift Wrapping - This sketch was definitely the most entertaining piece of the whole night. I did appreciate how this tried to top itself in terms of grossness. I genuinely had to wonder if Leslie had any lines in this sketch or not. I honestly don't know what was funnier between the over the top blood or the cheapness of the blood spurting props. Did anyone else notice Francos' fake foot came off before it was supposed to? A-
Scrudge Goes To A Party - This film underwhelmed me but I have to think that had something more to do with the fact that is simply followed a sketch with lots of fake blood. I did sort of like the premise of a Scrooge character being more of a modern day dick while still maintaining just the appearance and style of an 18th century old rich miser but something seemed lacking in both writing and execution. It's a little better on the second viewing. I did lije Becks' various insults and impositions on people but they seemed to run kind of a thin joke into the ground and even when he encountered Francos' character it didn't seem to escalate anywhere. Even the ending where Beck seems like he is apologizing but then intentionally moons everybody seemed like too much of a non sequitur even to me. Perhaps the thing that bothered to me the most was the fact that Becks' character was named "Scrudge" instead of just Scrooge. I was under the impression that either "A Christmas Carol" was somewhat in public domain or just that the family of Charles Dickens was just very unlitigious. I could understand the name change here in terms of creative license but otherwise I don't get it. D+
Spelling Bee - This was a funny live piece. I did like Kate and Alexs' back and forth. Francos' character indignantly revealing more and more disturbing personal facts about himself was funny and the featured players were serviceable enough in small teenage roles. Pete managed to get some funny lines here. B+
Update was mostly solid and a vast improvement on the previous week tonight. The only jokes that really stood out in the first part were the tangent that Al Franken inspired Che to go off on and Josts' Trump/Hanukkah party rant. I'm a bit conflicted about Cecilys' latest commentary. I thought it was her funniest appearance yet but mostly because of the legally dead/drug habits/flying foot jokes more than the real world commentary. I did like how they chose to tack in a Seth-and-Stefon type joke at the end (at least I think that's a joke since we haven't heard anything about Cecily getting engaged in real life yet...but if I'm wrong and that ring is real than kudos to her for both the engagement and choosing this as the way to break it to the world). In part two, the R. Kelly/UK ghost sex jokes stood out the most to me. I enjoyed Ches' short film more than I thought I woukd. I did like how he didn't overdo it and go full on "White Chicks Like Me" on us. I started to see right where it was going as soon as the first brunch/mimosas scene since, as I may have mentioned here before, one of Michael Ches' go to comedy tricks is to create parallels between two disparate groups of people. He still made it work in a big way here (even in a big enough way that his sudden dropping of the n-bomb in response to Alex didn't feel unnecessary or unwarranted). I did like how Redd was the only one who recognized him, too. B-
Za On Trial - This was definitely worth it just for the payoff. I wasn't that into the premise at first but I did like Francos' commitment to something so seemingly thin. I felt like I was watching a sketch that got cut fron Ryan Gosling episode just until Redds' appearance and Franco having photographic evidence of the murder and Petes' guilt being part of the twist ending. C+
Christmas Charity- This film was enjoyable in a subtle low-key way. I did feel like I should'be seen the joke coming a bit before the reveal but I did really enjoy the long, slow sentimental Schillers' Reel style buildup. I did think they could've trimmed the ending to this just a bit as it felt like they were really milking this for all it was worth there. B-
Pretty Mandy Reunion - This sketch was another enjoyable semi low key piece. Kudos to Heidi Gardner for getting possibly her most airtime of the season tonight. This was a more endearing character from her. It almost felt like if one of Kyle Mooneys' characters were written and performed more coherently and competently by a woman. I'm glad that the Dave Franco cameo they were obviously trying to build to really did happen and I liked how Franco was able to poke fun at his career here more effectively. B-
Now, just for fun, I thought I would try and rank all of James Francos' episodes from best to worst since he's hosted four times now. I'm going from memory on half of these because while I have reviewed all four of his shows, my reviews of his first two are lost to the ages. Here we go..
1. James Franco/Kings Of Leon/ (9.20.2008)
2. James Franco/SZA (12.9.2017)
3. James Franco/Nicki Minaj (12.6.2014)
4. James Franco/Muse (12.19.2009)
Now, for my updated rankings of this season...
1. Tiffany Haddish/Taylor Swift
2. Chance The Rapper/Eminem
3. James Franco/SZA
4. Saoirse Ronan/U2
5. Larry David/Miley Cyrus
6. Kumail Nanjiani/P!nk
7. Gal Gadot/Sam Smith
8.. Ryan Gosling/Jay-Z
Well, that was certainly a kick in the pants the show needed right now. Next week, Kevin Hart returns to host. Even though I've started to come around on Kevin more and more since he's been hosting, having him host the last show before Christmas feels a bit strange. Not quite as strange as having Casey Affleck host last Christmas but still just strange enough that he should probably be hosting on January 13th instead. See you then!
No comments:
Post a Comment